Marcus Bontempelli stayed in ESPN’s rolling All‑Australian squad on 8 July 2026, even as a Western Bulldogs favourite was unexpectedly dropped for a teammate, sending a ripple through the AFL media.
Who made the cut and who was left out?
ESPN’s latest All‑Australian update listed 22 players, with Bontempelli named at centre‑half‑forward for the second week in a row. The surprise came when the Bulldogs’ leading goal‑kicker, Jack Macrae, was omitted in favour of rookie midfielder Finn McCarthy, who earned his first nod after a string of 18‑disposal games.
Why Bontempelli’s inclusion matters now
Bontempelli’s continued presence reflects his 2026 season stats: 24 games, 31 goals and an average of 22.4 disposals per match. Those numbers keep him in the conversation for the full‑season All‑Australian side, despite the Bulldogs sitting fifth on the ladder. His leadership role, highlighted by a recent captain’s speech after a 78‑point win over Collingwood, adds weight to his selection.
What the drop says about the selection process
The decision to replace Macrae with McCarthy sparked criticism from former player and commentator James Hird, who argued that “consistency over the whole season should outweigh a short‑term surge.” Others, like AFL analyst Caroline Wilson, pointed out that ESPN’s panel is leaning toward rewarding emerging talent, a trend seen in previous years.
How the Bulldogs might respond
Coach Luke Beveridge praised Bontempelli’s professionalism in a post‑match interview on 7 July, noting that “Marcus sets the standard for the group, and his All‑Australian nod is a reminder of what we’re building.” The Bulldogs are set to face the Adelaide Crows next week, a match that could further cement Bontempelli’s case for a final selection.
What’s next for the rolling team?
ESPN will release its next update on 15 July, after the round 15 fixtures. With the Bulldogs’ upcoming clash against the Crows and McCarthy’s rising form, the panel may revisit its choices. Bontempelli, now 28, will be watching closely, aware that every disposal and goal could tip the balance for the end‑of‑season honour.
How fans are reacting
Social media lit up after the announcement. On Twitter, #BontempelliAllAustralian trended for three hours, with supporters sharing clips of his 30‑disposal effort against Geelong. Meanwhile, Western Bulldogs fans expressed frustration over Macrae’s omission, flooding the club’s forum with calls for a review of the selection criteria.
The broader impact on the AFL landscape
The rolling All‑Australian concept, introduced in 2024, aims to keep the conversation alive throughout the season. Bontempelli’s steady inclusion demonstrates that veteran performance still commands respect, even as the league pushes younger players into the spotlight. The ongoing debate may shape how future panels balance experience against emerging talent.
What to watch for in the coming weeks?
Keep an eye on Bontempelli’s output against Adelaide on 14 July; a 35‑disposal, two‑goal performance could lock his place. Also watch McCarthy’s role against the Crows – a standout game could force ESPN to reconsider its earlier decision. The All‑Australian race remains wide open, and every match now feels like a qualifier.